Top

Amazon Kindle – FAIL

July 19, 2009 by  

In a deliciously ironic moment, Amazon (who we quite like) have shot themselves in the foot after an incident with the Kindle e-reader.

I’ve fancied one of those for quite a while, but as I live in the UK, I’m unable to get one as they don’t work here yet.  Rumour is they will be available by Christmas if Amazon can get phone network (Whispernet) and publisher agreements settled.

The way it works is, you buy a Kindle and you also get a connection to the Amazon marketplace via Whispernet to allow you to purchase electronic versions of books and magazines which you can then read on the Kindle.

Whispernet is a data-only mobile phone connection, and is how a customer downloads their purchases.  In the US they use Sprint’s network, which uses a different connectivity technology to the GSM we use here in the UK.  That means US Kindles wont work over here, and is why it hasn’t yet been available to purchase.

If the rumours are true, then we could see Kindles go on sale soon here in the UK and I would have been in the market for one of those.

Would.

But now, there’s no way I’d touch one with a barge pole.

It turns out that hidden in the licence agreement it says you don’t actually own the electronic products you PURCHASE, you’re only renting them from Amazon and they can remotely remove (or amend) them at any time from YOUR Kindle via their Whispernet.

Ouch!

This has come to light after a number of people have found that their copy of George Orwell’s 1984 has been removed from their Kindle and a refund has been given.  It seems that Amazon have found that the third party publisher who was selling it in the market place didn’t own the rights to it in the US.  The word is that copyright on the ebook has expired in the rest of the world, but not yet in the US due to their out of date copyright laws.

We don’t yet know the full details, but it’s truly ironic that the book should be 1984.

So Amazon can at their decision and discretion arbitrarily remove products you’ve purchased in good faith.

It raises a number of disturbing points which I think need addressing publicly by Amazon.

#1 – If Amazon can remove as well as add products to your personal paid for library, what’s to stop them from applying new more onerous terms and conditions too?  Remember these people had purchased books that disappeared from their personal ebook reader and they were then refunded.  They had no choice in the matter.

#2 – If Amazon change their terms and conditions and start charging a monthly rental, then what happens?

#3 – If you opt out of the additional monthly charge, does the Kindle you’ve purchased become a lump of technology that no longer works?

#4 – Do the ebooks you’ve purchased (sorry, rented) disappear?

#5 – If so, could you then ask for your money back on the Kindle you’ve purchased?

#6 – If Amazon can remove products you’ve purchased from them, then I have to assume they can also remove ANY product from the Kindle, including ebooks I’ve purchased from other sites.

#7 – Which means that Amazon know what’s on my Kindle at any point, including stuff I might not want anyone else to know about.  Rights to privacy raise their head.

And on, and on…

It’s a minefield.  These and many other questions need answering properly.

Effectively, Amazon OWN your Kindle.  All they’ve done is rented it to you.  As it’s quite an expensive bit of kit, for me, that’s not good enough.  If I buy a piece of hardware, then it’s mine.  I don’t want anybody sneakily taking anything off something I’ve purchased while I’m asleep.

Now this would have been a non-issue if Amazon had first apologised and explained, then refunded their customers with double the purchased amount.

But they didn’t take the care to do so, and now this has exploded into a PR nightmare.

So I’m sorry Amazon.  As much as I like love you, because of what’s happened the Kindle is a big FAIL, and I’ll be buying a Sony ereader instead.

-Techy

P.S. This has only affected US Citizens. The rest of us can legally get a free copy of 1984 from places like Project Gutenberg.  Here you go… http://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks01/0100021.txt

Share

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

To submit your comment, click the image below where it asks you to... Clickcha - The One-click Captcha
Bottom