Comments on: Who’s A Naughty Girl Then? http://www.teafriendsandchocolate.com/sue/2007/11/08/whos-a-naughty-girl-then/ Tue, 22 May 2012 03:11:46 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.3.2 By: Sue http://www.teafriendsandchocolate.com/sue/2007/11/08/whos-a-naughty-girl-then/#comment-6230 Sue Mon, 12 Nov 2007 13:25:12 +0000 http://www.teafriendsandchocolate.com/sue/2007/11/08/whos-a-naughty-girl-then/#comment-6230 I'm not surprised you disagreed, I did say it was my stance. It's not complex, I think it's a waste of time that's all. Would you read two pages then analyse what you've read? For me it takes the fun out of reading. Commenting on a whole book I can understand. I’m not surprised you disagreed, I did say it was my stance.

It’s not complex, I think it’s a waste of time that’s all. Would you read two pages then analyse what you’ve read?

For me it takes the fun out of reading. Commenting on a whole book I can understand.

]]> By: The Sister http://www.teafriendsandchocolate.com/sue/2007/11/08/whos-a-naughty-girl-then/#comment-6228 The Sister Mon, 12 Nov 2007 08:36:59 +0000 http://www.teafriendsandchocolate.com/sue/2007/11/08/whos-a-naughty-girl-then/#comment-6228 I am not understanding of this complex situation. So how can writing a comment about part of a book that you have read be out of context? You read a bit of a book and then you write about what you read. I would have thought that a) it showed that a child had read abook and b) that a child had some understanding about what he had read. So then if that child has good comprehension skills they write a solid comment that floors the teacher it is still then fulfilling class requirements and shows that the student is advancing in his reading and comprehension skills! I am not understanding of this complex situation. So how can writing a comment about part of a book that you have read be out of context?
You read a bit of a book and then you write about what you read. I would have thought that a) it showed that a child had read abook and b) that a child had some understanding about what he had read. So then if that child has good comprehension skills they write a solid comment that floors the teacher it is still then fulfilling class requirements and shows that the student is advancing in his reading and comprehension skills!

]]>